Xiaoyuan Liu is an Associate Professor of History at Iowa State University and a recent Fellow at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington.
发表于2024-12-22
Frontier Passages 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 边疆史 國家與族裔 刘晓原 近代史 中国研究 中国现代史 中国政治 民国
In this pathbreaking book, Xiaoyuan Liu establishes the ways in which the history of the Chinese Communist Party was, from the Yan’an period onward, intertwined with the ethnopolitics of the Chinese “periphery.” As a Han-dominated party, the CCP had to adapt to an inhospitable political environment, particularly among the Hui (Muslims) of northwest China and the Mongols of Inner Mongolia. Based on a careful examination of CCP and Soviet Comintern documents only recently available, Liu’s study shows why the CCP found itself unable to follow the Russian Bolshevik precedent by inciting separatism among the non-Han peoples as a stratagem for gaining national power. Rather than swallowing Marxist-Leninist dogma on “the nationalities question,” the CCP took a position closer to that of the Kuomintang, stressing the inclusiveness of the Han-dominated Chinese nation, “Zhongua Minzu.”
如今再看的话,无论是材料还是观点,就显得没什么新意了。中共民族政策在1921-1945固然是有“去苏维埃化”的部分,但并不是要彻底的去“去苏维埃化”。1949年后,更是如此。
评分教科书对那段时期简直可以说是空白,原始资料支撑起来的论点很有说服力,所有的行动都是为着政治利益服务的,其他的一切?什么是其他的一切,我只知道利益。
评分线条比较粗疏,其实完全可以压缩成一篇高质量论文。可以作为一个党国体制下边疆民族政策发展演变大纲,按图索骥看感兴趣的部分。
评分如今再看的话,无论是材料还是观点,就显得没什么新意了。中共民族政策在1921-1945固然是有“去苏维埃化”的部分,但并不是要彻底的去“去苏维埃化”。1949年后,更是如此。
评分线条比较粗疏,其实完全可以压缩成一篇高质量论文。可以作为一个党国体制下边疆民族政策发展演变大纲,按图索骥看感兴趣的部分。
Frontier Passages 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书