Christopher I. Beckwith is professor of Central Eurasian studies at Indiana University, Bloomington. His books include Warriors of the Cloisters, Empires of the Silk Road, and The Tibetan Empire in Central Asia (all Princeton). He is the recipient of a MacArthur Award.
发表于2024-11-26
Greek Buddha 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 佛教 白桂思 思想史 宗教 希腊化哲学 历史 語言學 英语
Greek Buddha shows how Buddhism shaped the philosophy of Pyrrho, the famous founder of Pyrrhonian scepticism in ancient Greece. Identifying Pyrrho’s basic teachings with those of Early Buddhism, Christopher I. Beckwith traces the origins of a major tradition in Greek philosophy to Gandhāra, a country in Central Asia and northwestern India.
Pyrrho of Elis accompanied Alexander the Great to Central Asia and India during the Graeco-Macedonian invasion and conquest of the Persian Empire in 334–324 BC, and while there met with teachers of Early Buddhism, a philosophy that Beckwith analyzes in depth. Using a range of primary sources, he systematically looks at the teachings and practices of Pyrrho and of Early Buddhism, including those preserved in testimonies by and about Pyrrho, in the report on Indian philosophy two decades later by the Seleucid ambassador Megasthenes, in the first-person edicts by the Indian king Devānāṃpriya Priyadarśi referring to a popular variety of the Dharma in the early third century BC, and in Taoist echoes of Gautama’s Dharma in Warring States China. Beckwith demonstrates how the teachings of Pyrrho agree closely with those of the Buddha śākyamuni, “the Scythian Sage.” In the process, he identifies eight distinct attested philosophical schools in ancient northwestern India and Central Asia, including Early Zoroastrianism, Early Brahmanism, and several forms of Early Buddhism. Beckwith then shows the influence that Pyrrho’s brand of scepticism had on the evolution of Western thought, first in Antiquity, and later, during the Enlightenment, on the great philosopher and self-proclaimed “Pyrrhonian,” David Hume.
Greek Buddha demonstrates that through Pyrrho, Early Buddhist thought had a significant impact on Western philosophy.
没有细读,但是作者的big picture就不是很convinced。我其实觉得使用buddhism这个词本身就是有问题的,用buddha更是太general了。佛教的各个时期和学派区别太大了,而且作者所谓的central idea,虽然不能说是错的,但是他的理解我没法认同。比如说,个人认为Pyrrho所谓的no-self是perspective的问题,这比“central idea”的无我浅太多太多了......不说深浅起码完全是不同的。但是appendix很有用,比正文更academic(。
评分没有细读,但是作者的big picture就不是很convinced。我其实觉得使用buddhism这个词本身就是有问题的,用buddha更是太general了。佛教的各个时期和学派区别太大了,而且作者所谓的central idea,虽然不能说是错的,但是他的理解我没法认同。比如说,个人认为Pyrrho所谓的no-self是perspective的问题,这比“central idea”的无我浅太多太多了......不说深浅起码完全是不同的。但是appendix很有用,比正文更academic(。
评分这本书已经超越了是佛陀影响皮浪还是the other way around,而是用语言学重构的思路去重构思想史,即皮浪主义就像一个思想的loan word,比任何normative Buddhism都更接近原始佛教。另外,对游牧民族与早期佛教关系的提及也很有趣,早期佛教徒生活方式多大程度反映游牧生活本身就值得写一本书。
评分没有细读,但是作者的big picture就不是很convinced。我其实觉得使用buddhism这个词本身就是有问题的,用buddha更是太general了。佛教的各个时期和学派区别太大了,而且作者所谓的central idea,虽然不能说是错的,但是他的理解我没法认同。比如说,个人认为Pyrrho所谓的no-self是perspective的问题,这比“central idea”的无我浅太多太多了......不说深浅起码完全是不同的。但是appendix很有用,比正文更academic(。
评分这本书已经超越了是佛陀影响皮浪还是the other way around,而是用语言学重构的思路去重构思想史,即皮浪主义就像一个思想的loan word,比任何normative Buddhism都更接近原始佛教。另外,对游牧民族与早期佛教关系的提及也很有趣,早期佛教徒生活方式多大程度反映游牧生活本身就值得写一本书。
Greek Buddha 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书