Joan Judge is Professor at York University. She is the author of The Precious Raft of History: The Past, the West, and the Woman Question in China and Print and Politics: ‘Shibao’ and the Culture of Reform in Late Qing China.
What can we learn about modern Chinese history by reading a marginalized set of materials from a widely neglected period? In Republican Lens, Joan Judge retrieves and revalorizes the vital brand of commercial culture that arose in the period surrounding China’s 1911 Revolution. Dismissed by high-minded ideologues of the late 1910s and largely overlooked in subsequent scholarship, this commercial culture has only recently begun to be rehabilitated in mainland China. Judge uses one of its most striking, innovative—and continually mischaracterized—products, the journal Funü shibao (The women’s eastern times), as a lens onto the early years of China’s first Republic. Redeeming both the value of the medium and the significance of the era, she demonstrates the extent to which the commercial press channeled and helped constitute key epistemic and gender trends in China’s revolutionary twentieth century.
The book develops a cross-genre and inter-media method for reading the periodical press and gaining access to the complexities of the past. Drawing on the full materiality of the medium, Judge reads cover art, photographs, advertisements, and poetry, editorials, essays, and readers’ columns in conjunction with and against one another, as well as in their broader print, historical and global contexts. This yields insights into fundamental tensions that governed both the journal and the early Republic. It also highlights processes central to the arc of twentieth-century knowledge culture and social change: the valorization and scientization of the notion of “experience,” the public actualization of “Republican Ladies,” and the amalgamation of “Chinese medicine” and scientific biomedicine. It further revives the journal’s editors, authors, medical experts, artists, and, most notably, its little known female contributors. Republican Lens captures the ingenuity of a journal that captures the chaotic potentialities within China’s early Republic and its global twentieth century.
發表於2024-12-28
Republican Lens 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
圖書標籤: 海外中國研究 近代史 新聞史 季傢珍 中國近代史 性彆 婦女時報 書籍史
以《婦女時報》作為核心材料來討論gender和visuality。並且引入瞭everyday life這個概念,其實覺得沒有超齣Barbara Mittler在<A Newspaper for China>裡對女性讀者的討論。
評分very sloppy and problematic definition of "everydayness"
評分用瞭很多概念,但感覺沒寫齣什麼新意,尤其是situated reading體現得不明顯
評分以《婦女時報》作為核心材料來討論gender和visuality。並且引入瞭everyday life這個概念,其實覺得沒有超齣Barbara Mittler在<A Newspaper for China>裡對女性讀者的討論。
評分不打五星是為瞭把五星留給女神,但這本書值得五星。Judge將visual study引入社會史研究領域,這得益於她與視覺藝術學者的閤作,而且效果不錯,對民國時期大量照片插畫廣告畫的分析補充瞭先前期刊研究著重文本的傾嚮。研究選取瞭特彆的曆史時期:晚清民初1906-1917,始於辛亥之前結於五四之前;這一時期相對新文化運動報刊研究是一個盲點。作為曆史研究而非純媒介研究,作者采用瞭立體的研究方法:1)horizontal reading(同一issue內不同類型文章的研究,而非media study常用的對同一主題不同issue的研究)2)integrated(與同時期和後續齣版物:女性期刊和courtesan相冊的比較研究)3)situated(基於特定時期政治曆史文化背景的分析)。
Republican Lens 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載