发表于2024-12-23
Curating Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 历史 文化史 历史学 博物馆 中国当代史 PRC文化史 海外中国研究 中共党史
How did China’s Communist Revolution transform the nation’s political culture? In this rich and vivid history of the Mao period (1949-1976), Denise Y. Ho examines the relationship between its exhibits and its political movements, arguing that exhibitions made revolution material. Case studies from Shanghai show how revolution was curated: museum workers collected cultural and revolutionary relics; neighborhoods, schools, and work units mounted and narrated local displays; and exhibits provided ritual space for both ideological lessons and political campaigns. Using archival sources, ephemera, interviews, and other historical materials, Curating Revolution traces the process by which exhibitions were developed, presented, and received. Its examples range from the First Party Congress Site and the Shanghai Museum to the “class education” and Red Guard exhibits that accompanied the Socialist Education Movement and the Cultural Revolution. With its socialist museums and new exhibitions, the exhibitionary culture of the Mao era operated in two modes: that of a state in power and that of a state in revolution. Both reflecting and making revolution, these forms remain part of China’s revolutionary legacy today.
长处是选题+扎实的资料搜集。但问题也很多,首先是state/revolution的两种mode实在是太泛泛(且老生常谈)而流于空洞。其次是对exihibition这一所谓medium的探讨不够深入,虽说聚焦在“展览”可以让材料的选择变得非常集中,但如果只是从material的角度来定义exihibition,那么一切ritual和performance都是,这样一来这个范畴本身就失去了解释力。总的感觉是用一个新颖的题目重复了一些已知的结论,但没有提出一个好的研究问题。
评分平铺直叙而已,了无新意。
评分视角新,材料实,蛮会讲故事的。两种(互相交叠的)模式也有启发,总体是沿着“物质性”“地区性”“非目的性”的文化史路子在走的。但是做社科研究的看起来还是有点不够过瘾。
评分用时空的物质化编写PRC革命与建设的合法性与正当性,本来就是感兴趣的题目,越读越发现操作材料的手法颇为高明,非常好读
评分口述史,CCP propaganda研究的范本之作。
Curating Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书