The increasing numbers of scholars, policy-makers, and political activists who are concerned with questions of physical and cognitive disability will warmly welcome Henri-Jacques Stiker's book, the first to attempt to provide a framework for analyzing disability through the ages. Published in 1997 in France as "Corps infirmes et societes" and available now in an excellent English translation, the book traces the history of western cultural responses to disability, from ancient times to the present.In this volume, Stiker examines a fundamental issue in contemporary Western discourse on disability: the cultural assumption that equality/sameness/similarity is always desired by those in society. He highlights the consequences of such a mindset, illustrating the intolerance of diversity and individualism that arises from placing such importance on equality. Importantly, Stiker does not hesitate to assert his own stance on the issues he discusses: that difference is not only acceptable, but that it is desirable, that it is necessary.The author goes beyond anecdotal history to traverse a little known history, penetrating to the heart of collective attitudes and reflecting on elements of policy. The sweep is broad; from a rereading and reinterpretation of the Oedipus myth to current legislation regarding disablity, he proposes an analytical history that demonstrates how societies reveal themselves through their attitudes towards disability, at times in unexpected ways, since the study of detail is often the best entry into the whole of a culture. The book will be of interest to scholars of disability, historians, social scientists, cultural anthropologists, and those who are intrigued by the role that culture plays in the development of language and thought surrounding the disabled.Henri-Jacques Stiker is Director of Research and member of the department of the History and Civilization of Western Societies, University of Paris VII.
發表於2024-12-23
A History of Disability 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
圖書標籤: history
作者通過構建一個模型,來說明不同時代對“disability”的不同理解及其演變:由生物化(個體)、宗教化(人神),到社會化(群體)和醫療化(個體)。不過,對“disability”的理解總是相對的。正常人在某些特殊情況下,具有殘疾人所具備的特徵。比如,推著嬰兒車的母親。
評分作者通過構建一個模型,來說明不同時代對“disability”的不同理解及其演變:由生物化(個體)、宗教化(人神),到社會化(群體)和醫療化(個體)。不過,對“disability”的理解總是相對的。正常人在某些特殊情況下,具有殘疾人所具備的特徵。比如,推著嬰兒車的母親。
評分太棒。曆史脈絡清晰,架構宏大,不失nuance。不少講disability曆史的對宗教刻畫分析不夠,這本沒忽略這一重點。亮點是Birth of Rehabilitation這一章,分析這一話語/産業下的工業自由主義邏輯,直擊紅心。就是展望未來啥的感覺普通和前麵激進的批評對不上……話說,沒讀過多少法國作傢的英文翻譯,感覺和英文學術文風不同,十分舒爽,為什麼呢?
評分作者通過構建一個模型,來說明不同時代對“disability”的不同理解及其演變:由生物化(個體)、宗教化(人神),到社會化(群體)和醫療化(個體)。不過,對“disability”的理解總是相對的。正常人在某些特殊情況下,具有殘疾人所具備的特徵。比如,推著嬰兒車的母親。
評分太棒。曆史脈絡清晰,架構宏大,不失nuance。不少講disability曆史的對宗教刻畫分析不夠,這本沒忽略這一重點。亮點是Birth of Rehabilitation這一章,分析這一話語/産業下的工業自由主義邏輯,直擊紅心。就是展望未來啥的感覺普通和前麵激進的批評對不上……話說,沒讀過多少法國作傢的英文翻譯,感覺和英文學術文風不同,十分舒爽,為什麼呢?
A History of Disability 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載