發表於2024-12-23
The Teleology of the Modern Nation-State 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
圖書標籤: 民族國傢 比較政治 政治 中國近代史 中國政治 近代史 海外中國研究 法律史與法律文化
讀PP的文章
評分總體來說強調國族和其曆史的現代建構性,但路數分為兩種。一是通過還原曆史復雜性:Mair的文章指齣北方/西北遊牧民族可能並不是外來入侵者,而是曆史上state formation的主要角色。Kirby的文章指齣現代民族國傢意識自晚清纔齣現,1911革命建立的共和國對於清帝國的繼承涉及復雜的建構整閤,不同意識形態、政治計劃的競爭,並非綫性發展。第二種是考慮民族國傢建構/建設中帝國曆史的遺産:Crossley的文章分析共産主義國傢和清帝國都依賴universalism, transformationalism的意識形態來吸收文化他者。Perdue比較清帝國和現代國傢在機構、治理上遇到的類似問題,並依賴邊境視角討論國傢建構的復綫曆史(Duara)。
評分讀PP的文章
評分As Perdue states, the observation by Lucian Pye of China not having a mature nationalism is accurate (for a sanity check, what is an un-Chinese behavior; and what is un-American or un-British), though his diagnosis of civilization state is inaccurate. To Perdue the problem is the empire. It all points to a gaping hole in the notion of China..
評分As Perdue states, the observation by Lucian Pye of China not having a mature nationalism is accurate (for a sanity check, what is an un-Chinese behavior; and what is un-American or un-British), though his diagnosis of civilization state is inaccurate. To Perdue the problem is the empire. It all points to a gaping hole in the notion of China..
The Teleology of the Modern Nation-State 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載