Louis Riel is regarded by some as a hero and visionary, by others as a madman and misguided religious zealot. The Métis leader who fought for the rights of his people against an encroaching tide of white settlers helped establish the province of Manitoba before escaping to the United States. Gabriel Dumont was a successful hunter and Métis chief, a man tested by warfare, a pragmatist who differed from the devout Riel. Giller Prize–winning novelist Joseph Boyden argues that Dumont, part of a delegation that had sought out Riel in exile, may not have foreseen the impact on the Métis cause of bringing Riel home. While making rational demands of Sir John A. Macdonald’s government, Riel seemed increasingly overtaken by a messianic mission. His execution in 1885 by the Canadian government still reverberates today. Boyden provides fresh, controversial insight into these two seminal Canadian figures and how they shaped the country.

Boyden boldly posits that Dumont and the Metis would have been better off not bringing Riel back to lead them. He suggests that Dumont didn’t know what a broiling cauldron of a man Riel was at that point. This may cause controversy in academic circles in Canada. Riel is looked upon as a saint among the Metis, and a madman among academics like Flanagan. He considered himself the prophet of the New World, and that kind of hubris only distanced the Metis from their desire to be recognized by the government as a distinct people with distinct rights.