Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书


Agrarian Revolution

简体网页||繁体网页

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书 著者简介


Agrarian Revolution 电子书 图书目录




点击这里下载
    


想要找书就要到 本本书屋
立刻按 ctrl+D收藏本页
你会得到大惊喜!!

发表于2024-12-28

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书



喜欢 Agrarian Revolution 电子书 的读者还喜欢


Agrarian Revolution 电子书 读后感

评分

评分

评分

评分

评分

类似图书 点击查看全场最低价
出版者:Free Press
作者:Jeffrey M. Paige
出品人:
页数:448
译者:
出版时间:1978-4-1
价格:USD 20.00
装帧:Paperback
isbn号码:9780029235508
丛书系列:

图书标签: 社会运动  比较政治  革命  政治学  农村研究  比较历史  OperationUranus   


Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书 图书描述

The specter haunting sociology is that the great political events of history still seem connected to agriculture. Barrington Moore even linked agriculture to the rise of Hitler. Yet we supposedly live in an industrial and post-industrial world in the imperialist countries.

This book is tough reading and contains the use of advanced statistical methods. As such it will mostly end up in college-educated people's hands.

Here I will only touch on one issue among many mentioned in the book. In sociological literature the concern or topic of interest is often called "collective violence." In connection to this, those of neo-classical economic bent have raised the "free rider problem." According to this theory, the rational actor benefits from revolutions created by others, but does not risk revolution him or herself.

We believe we have answered that question directly elsewhere, but let's look at what Jeffery Paige has done in that context. Instead of raising merely a theoretical question about the free rider or an ideological question as to whether the "free rider" is good or bad, what Paige has done is so much better.

Paige has taken data and shown that collective violence does exist, can be measured and has identifiable causations. Instead of wondering whether collective violence can happen by simply asking about the "free rider problem," Paige collected the data on incidents of violence and showed that people around the world do in certain circumstances take up revolutionary violence. When we know that such violence will occur and under what conditions, the question of "free riders" seems rather silly and ideologically motivated. It's a case where facts need to substitute for theoretical concern alone. The question of how the tooth-fairy takes away the teeth at night is indeed scientific, but if we ask it again and again, we have fallen victim to ideology.

A lesser discussed aspect of the book is the situation where revolutionary violence will not occur and that is in the setting where social logic dictates compromise between capital and wage-earners. Since it is in fact true that no successful revolution has occurred in an industrialized country--except for Stalin's Red Army invasion of Germany--it might well be that capitalism succeeds in exporting its political crisis to the Third World. Paige shows that revolution happens in export-agriculture sectors, where agrarian elites find themselves in a zero-sum struggle with peasants by the very nature of the business these elites are in.

Paige operationalizes something similar to our line. We at MIM see that the more advanced capitalist countries did in fact go the reformist road of compromise. The most advanced produced conservative middle-classes out of the former ranks of the proletariat.

It's tempting in imperialist countries to ignore the agrarian reality affecting most people in the world even in 2003. Because advanced capitalist countries do not truly assist in economic development of agrarian countries and in fact support elites holding back those countries, Agrarian Revolution is still terribly relevant.

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
想要找书就要到 本本书屋
立刻按 ctrl+D收藏本页
你会得到大惊喜!!

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 用户评价

评分

感觉Paige的categories并不适用于中国(古代王朝末期)的农民运动进程,但对于拉丁美洲的解释则相对深有启发。

评分

感觉Paige的categories并不适用于中国(古代王朝末期)的农民运动进程,但对于拉丁美洲的解释则相对深有启发。

评分

从横向上来说,基于cultivation与income建立的理想模型虽然精致,但是过于,甚至可以说是完全,依赖于对经济动机及经济现象的分析。即使找到了用以比较的不同地区事例,但整体读罢,不过是单纯从经济数据的差异上,套上既有建立的理论,而缺乏对reform, revolt, revolution的多向度考察,如历史、文化等,使得本作虽然细致,但仍然缺乏如之前Moore,或者之后Scott作品的说服力。从纵向上,Paige大多事实资料来源于报纸报道,与横向多维度的检讨的缺失一样,其对几个国家考察,也成了一种纯粹现象学式的归纳。

评分

从横向上来说,基于cultivation与income建立的理想模型虽然精致,但是过于,甚至可以说是完全,依赖于对经济动机及经济现象的分析。即使找到了用以比较的不同地区事例,但整体读罢,不过是单纯从经济数据的差异上,套上既有建立的理论,而缺乏对reform, revolt, revolution的多向度考察,如历史、文化等,使得本作虽然细致,但仍然缺乏如之前Moore,或者之后Scott作品的说服力。从纵向上,Paige大多事实资料来源于报纸报道,与横向多维度的检讨的缺失一样,其对几个国家考察,也成了一种纯粹现象学式的归纳。

评分

从横向上来说,基于cultivation与income建立的理想模型虽然精致,但是过于,甚至可以说是完全,依赖于对经济动机及经济现象的分析。即使找到了用以比较的不同地区事例,但整体读罢,不过是单纯从经济数据的差异上,套上既有建立的理论,而缺乏对reform, revolt, revolution的多向度考察,如历史、文化等,使得本作虽然细致,但仍然缺乏如之前Moore,或者之后Scott作品的说服力。从纵向上,Paige大多事实资料来源于报纸报道,与横向多维度的检讨的缺失一样,其对几个国家考察,也成了一种纯粹现象学式的归纳。

Agrarian Revolution 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书


分享链接









相关图书




本站所有内容均为互联网搜索引擎提供的公开搜索信息,本站不存储任何数据与内容,任何内容与数据均与本站无关,如有需要请联系相关搜索引擎包括但不限于百度google,bing,sogou

友情链接

© 2024 onlinetoolsland.com All Rights Reserved. 本本书屋 版权所有