Guy is associate professor of history at the University of Washington.
发表于2024-12-22
The Emperor's Four Treasures 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
一句话评价:细节功夫不行,人文关怀负分,只有(几十年以前的)标新立异的观点。 先挑能夸的点,本书相对来说最有价值的部分是四、五两章。 第四章强调了皇帝、官僚、学者的立场区别:沽名钓誉的皇帝有些急于求成,务实的刘统勋试图限制工程的规模,朱筠和他的幕友们则希望借...
评分一句话评价:细节功夫不行,人文关怀负分,只有(几十年以前的)标新立异的观点。 先挑能夸的点,本书相对来说最有价值的部分是四、五两章。 第四章强调了皇帝、官僚、学者的立场区别:沽名钓誉的皇帝有些急于求成,务实的刘统勋试图限制工程的规模,朱筠和他的幕友们则希望借...
评分一句话评价:细节功夫不行,人文关怀负分,只有(几十年以前的)标新立异的观点。 先挑能夸的点,本书相对来说最有价值的部分是四、五两章。 第四章强调了皇帝、官僚、学者的立场区别:沽名钓誉的皇帝有些急于求成,务实的刘统勋试图限制工程的规模,朱筠和他的幕友们则希望借...
评分https://wordpress.com/post/athenacool.wordpress.com/3825 皇帝的四库:乾隆朝晚期的学者与国家 [美]盖博坚 / 郑云艳 / 中国人民大学出版社 / 2019-10 子扉我 2019年秋 申城西楼 原载回响编辑部微信2019年12月28日 正文字数不能少于140字
评分最近同时在看《皇帝的四库》与黑格尔的《历史哲学》,突然有了一点联想。18世纪,中国发生了汉宋学之争,两派都不否定真理,认为古代圣人是思想和智慧的终极来源。但是宋学一派认为“人性定义了道,反过来又决定了教化的特征”,主张通过经验,义理来理解真理。汉学则认为真理...
图书标签: 海外中国研究 清史 历史 文化史 英文原版 知识分子 盖博坚 近现代史
The compilation of the Complete Library of the Four Treasuries ("Ssu-k'u ch'uan-shu") was one of the most ambitious intellectual projects of the Ch'ing dynasty. Initiated by imperial command in 1772, the project sought to evaluate, edit, and reproduce the finest Chinese writings in the four traditional categories: Confucian classics, histories, philosophy, and "belles lettres." The final products, created over a twenty-two year period, were an annotated catalog of some ten thousand titles and seven new manuscript libraries of nearly thirty-six hundred titles. The project had its darker side as well, for together with the evaluation of books there developed a campaign of censorship and proscription. Guy's study gives a balanced account of the project and its significance. Dozens of celebrated Chinese scholars willingly participated in the project, though it was sponsored by the Manchu emperor, and Guy explains their reasons for doing so. He also reconsiders the issue of censorship, arguing that it grew as much from tensions and jealousies within the intellectual elite as from imperial command. Guy's work will be useful to all those interested in the relationship between intellectuals and the state in late imperial China.
特别注重institutional environment 和各级地方的参与...思想史与政治史的结合
评分总体还可以,盖坚博的一些判断在当时的史料情况下还是有见地的。如清代考据学不是因文字狱兴起,明末就有迹象;比如清代禁书在1774年后才体系化。都比胡适、萧一山大而化之的说法精准。作者称用了台湾的档案,书中实在没怎么看出来。
评分insightful, clear, and well organized book.
评分特别注重institutional environment 和各级地方的参与...思想史与政治史的结合
评分insightful, clear, and well organized book.
The Emperor's Four Treasures 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书