发表于2024-11-05
Figures of Resistance 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 平安时代 源氏物语 日本 四 古典文学 古今集 YL English
In this revisionist study of texts from the mid-Heian period in Japan, H. Richard Okada offers new readings of three well-known tales: "The Tale of the Bamboo-cutter", "The Tale of Ise", and "The Tale of Genji". Okada contends that the cultural and gendered significance of these works has been distorted by previous commentaries and translations belonging to the larger patriarchal and colonialist discourse of Western civilization. He goes on to suggest that this universalist discourse, which silences the feminine aspects of these texts and subsumes their writing in misapplied Western canonical literary terms, is sanctioned and maintained by the discipline of Japanese literature. Okada develops a highly original and sophisticated reading strategy that demonstrates how readers might understand texts belonging to a different time and place without being complicit in their assimilation to categories derived from Western literary traditions.The author's reading stratgey is based on the texts' own resistance to modes of analysis that employ such Western canonical terms as novel, lyric, and third-person narrative. Emphasis is also given to the distinctive cultural circles, as well as socio-political and genealogical circumstances that surrounded the emergence of the texts. Indispensable readings for specialists in literature, cultural studies, and Japanese literature and history, "Figures of Resistance" will also appeal to general readers interested in the problems and complexities of studying another culture.
這本書被以haruo shirane為代表的學者們用不同的方式,不斷地批評,反諷,和責罵,以至於如果因為讀不懂Okada複雜的思維邏輯,想著先讀讀book reviews再讀它的話,會被review們千變萬化,想方設法黑okada的文字惹到笑到無法好好的正式這本書( ̄▽ ̄)
评分這本書被以haruo shirane為代表的學者們用不同的方式,不斷地批評,反諷,和責罵,以至於如果因為讀不懂Okada複雜的思維邏輯,想著先讀讀book reviews再讀它的話,會被review們千變萬化,想方設法黑okada的文字惹到笑到無法好好的正式這本書( ̄▽ ̄)
评分這本書被以haruo shirane為代表的學者們用不同的方式,不斷地批評,反諷,和責罵,以至於如果因為讀不懂Okada複雜的思維邏輯,想著先讀讀book reviews再讀它的話,會被review們千變萬化,想方設法黑okada的文字惹到笑到無法好好的正式這本書( ̄▽ ̄)
评分序言裡的hook很有意思:詹明信聽了作者的一個presentation,提了一串問題,致使Okada回家埋頭大改此書。然而intro感覺和正文不是同一本書……Intro無論是對現有方法論的反思還是其中的高度理論自覺都看得我很期待,雖然不免“過兩級”之處,但畢竟在這個領域中不多見,尤其是放在當年。可是後面的具體章節似乎沒能完全實現他的野望。解構的姿態確實做出來了:對“起源”的抵抗,seriallity,延異…但另一方面,文章寫得支離,古今集一章找不到結論是怎麼出來的。雖說reviewer的反應過激了些,但誠如某位reviewer所說,這本書這麼讓人難以進入,Okada的寫作風格難辭其咎。
评分這本書被以haruo shirane為代表的學者們用不同的方式,不斷地批評,反諷,和責罵,以至於如果因為讀不懂Okada複雜的思維邏輯,想著先讀讀book reviews再讀它的話,會被review們千變萬化,想方設法黑okada的文字惹到笑到無法好好的正式這本書( ̄▽ ̄)
Figures of Resistance 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书