发表于2024-11-25
On the Ego and on God 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: Marion 笛卡尔 哲学 马里翁 西方哲学 我思 近代早期 宗教
In this most recent of his seminal studies on Descartes, Jean-Luc Marion brings together essays on the topics of the ego and of God, most of them previously unavailable in English. More than any other of Marion's works, the book illustrates the profound connection between his phenomenological concerns and his writings on Descartes. Liberating God and the self from the constrictions of metaphysics are fundamental tenets of Marion's theological and phenomenological work. This book highlights the same topics in the philosophy of Descartes. In Part I ("On the Ego"), Marion explores the alterity of the Cartesian ego, arguing that it is not as solitary as has often been assumed, and shows how Descartes' writings themselves are framed by dialogue. He explicates the status of the rule of truth in the Meditations, on the one hand highlighting how Descartes' argument is not circular, on the other hand showing how Pascal responds to and alters Descartes. He also elucidates the ambivalent status of the concept of substance in Descartes by returning to its roots in the philosophy of Suarez. In Part II ("On God"), Marion returns to the important Cartesian thesis of the creation of the eternal truths, setting it in the context of the claims of earlier thinkers and showing its demise in philosophies following Descartes. The study closes with a careful delineation of the concept of causa sui and a detailed survey of the idea of God in seventeenth-century thought.
马里翁的笛卡尔研究系列,以对话理论解读笛卡尔的我思,视角十分独特,习惯了康德、胡塞尔、海德格尔对笛卡尔的主观解读,再看马里翁的解读,顿时发现了一个焕然一新的笛卡尔。 不过,原著是法文版的,这本英文翻译还算可以。
评分新颖大胆的解读奠基于深厚的哲学史功底,真是笛卡尔研究中的上乘之作。
评分3/6。继笛卡尔式问题之后的又一力作,不得不说形而上学研究的问题根本上是我和上帝,我思的原初他者,永恒真理的创造和神概念的梳理非常有意思,不过我的最后一篇“实体与持存”,和经院哲学尤其是苏亚雷斯的讨论仍然需要这方面的专业知识。
评分马里翁的笛卡尔研究系列,以对话理论解读笛卡尔的我思,视角十分独特,习惯了康德、胡塞尔、海德格尔对笛卡尔的主观解读,再看马里翁的解读,顿时发现了一个焕然一新的笛卡尔。 不过,原著是法文版的,这本英文翻译还算可以。
评分只读了第一篇。感觉Marion的解释很符合我的想法,那个主动怀疑的我根本就不是真正的我嘛,怎么看都像是一个他者,唯一确定的似乎只有be acted on的我。
On the Ego and on God 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书