Vivienne Shue is Professor and Chair of the Department of Government at Cornell University.
发表于2024-11-21
The Reach of the State 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 政治学 海外中国研究 社会学 中国研究 中国政治 乡村政治 Shue 政治社会学
These four conceptual and critical essays on state and society in contemporary China argue vigorously against the grain of prevailing scholarly interpretation. In substantive content, they explore two major themes from different historical and theoretical points of departure.
First, the author argues that the party/state under Mao fell far short of the full control over China's peasant society that outside observers often assumed it had achieved. She shows, instead, how the Maoist state frequently pursued policies that in fact had the ironic effect of strengthening the resistance of rural communities against the central political apparatus. Second, she contends that once the true limitations on the Maoist state's power in rural areas are rightly understood, it becomes clear that one effect of the post-Mao economic and political reforms may be to enhance rather than to diminish the state's authority in the countryside — despite all the reformists' rhetoric to the contrary.
These essays on "how to think about the Chinese state" are designed to stimulate debate about assumptions and methods in the field of Chinese political analysis. The controversies they raise, however, make them highly relevant to scholars outside Chinese studies who are interested in theories of the state, in the interrelations of state and society, and in the fate of the peasantry under socialism.
國家的整合、抽取、介入和地方自主性。從毛時代的蜂巢到鄧時代的網,鄧(聯盟)以“現代化”為口號,完成模式的轉換。在之前,1911年革命之後,因為一直很苦逼,軍閥、日寇還有叛亂,國家是比較無力的。 總之,主要的立足點在於打臉“totalitarianism”,提出一個研究中國的新的可能,更希望超越這個可能。
评分前三十年的中国政治并不是简单的全能主义式,国家的触手并未能实现控制乡村,乡村社会呈现蜂窝状,乡村精英有一定的保护主义倾向,反而是改革开放后,地方政府公司化让政府之手伸得更远。其实,这个研究和卢晖临的研究本质上有些类似性,并且卢晖临做得更好。
评分Interesting argument which I cannot agree
评分架构清晰,材料匀称妥帖,也是社会学研究的典范。第三章写得挺精彩的,拉出了历史的脉络,格局也很大,不过对于论证还没有能力批判吧。(作者提出的剧情翻转在于:被西方认为极权主义的毛时代,地方其实有自主性,有独立能力,不那么容易被国家穿透,比如人民公社,所谓cellularity结构;而邓的改革则并非国家的撤退,反而经过“现代化”和市场的扩张,原有阻碍国家reach的架构被削弱瓦解了,农民可能直接暴露在国家和市场面前,国家权力虽有边界但是可以do more)
评分赶在最后几分钟提交了读书报告。以前耳闻目睹的乡村治理细节片段经过作者的排列组合分析,立刻与中观组织宏观社会政治背景勾连起来。
The Reach of the State 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书