发表于2024-11-23
Competing Devotions 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 女性 labor gender and
The wrenching decision facing successful women choosing between demanding careers and intensive family lives has been the subject of many articles and books, most of which propose strategies for resolving the dilemma. Competing Devotions focuses on broader social and cultural forces that create women's identities and shape their understanding of what makes life worth living.
第二遍,断断续续两天看完。中间几度要无聊到昏睡过去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上来说devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不说这个culture到底是什么。换句话说这个田野要换个non-western语境,北美学者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接毙掉。全书细碎且多到记不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也没有想对话private/public distinction文献的意思,gender部分老生常谈毫无新意。社会学写作什么时候又能脱离研究者的政治立场?若是真的脱离又怎么能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同题材书真的好一大截。
评分呼应当下中国密集型母职的兴起。不是人类学的写法,篇幅略拖沓,核心部分的案例比较更适合写成论文。
评分第二遍,断断续续两天看完。中间几度要无聊到昏睡过去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上来说devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不说这个culture到底是什么。换句话说这个田野要换个non-western语境,北美学者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接毙掉。全书细碎且多到记不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也没有想对话private/public distinction文献的意思,gender部分老生常谈毫无新意。社会学写作什么时候又能脱离研究者的政治立场?若是真的脱离又怎么能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同题材书真的好一大截。
评分第二遍,断断续续两天看完。中间几度要无聊到昏睡过去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上来说devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不说这个culture到底是什么。换句话说这个田野要换个non-western语境,北美学者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接毙掉。全书细碎且多到记不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也没有想对话private/public distinction文献的意思,gender部分老生常谈毫无新意。社会学写作什么时候又能脱离研究者的政治立场?若是真的脱离又怎么能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同题材书真的好一大截。
评分第二遍,断断续续两天看完。中间几度要无聊到昏睡过去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上来说devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不说这个culture到底是什么。换句话说这个田野要换个non-western语境,北美学者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接毙掉。全书细碎且多到记不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也没有想对话private/public distinction文献的意思,gender部分老生常谈毫无新意。社会学写作什么时候又能脱离研究者的政治立场?若是真的脱离又怎么能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同题材书真的好一大截。
Competing Devotions 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书