The wrenching decision facing successful women choosing between demanding careers and intensive family lives has been the subject of many articles and books, most of which propose strategies for resolving the dilemma. Competing Devotions focuses on broader social and cultural forces that create women's identities and shape their understanding of what makes life worth living.
發表於2024-11-04
Competing Devotions 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
圖書標籤: 女性 labor gender and
第二遍,斷斷續續兩天看完。中間幾度要無聊到昏睡過去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上來說devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不說這個culture到底是什麼。換句話說這個田野要換個non-western語境,北美學者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接斃掉。全書細碎且多到記不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也沒有想對話private/public distinction文獻的意思,gender部分老生常談毫無新意。社會學寫作什麼時候又能脫離研究者的政治立場?若是真的脫離又怎麼能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同題材書真的好一大截。
評分第二遍,斷斷續續兩天看完。中間幾度要無聊到昏睡過去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上來說devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不說這個culture到底是什麼。換句話說這個田野要換個non-western語境,北美學者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接斃掉。全書細碎且多到記不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也沒有想對話private/public distinction文獻的意思,gender部分老生常談毫無新意。社會學寫作什麼時候又能脫離研究者的政治立場?若是真的脫離又怎麼能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同題材書真的好一大截。
評分呼應當下中國密集型母職的興起。不是人類學的寫法,篇幅略拖遝,核心部分的案例比較更適閤寫成論文。
評分第二遍,斷斷續續兩天看完。中間幾度要無聊到昏睡過去...culture is JUST taken for granted—先上來說devotion schema is culturally constructed, 但又不說這個culture到底是什麼。換句話說這個田野要換個non-western語境,北美學者一句what is culture, why is it important 直接斃掉。全書細碎且多到記不住的grounded theory式案例,作者似乎也沒有想對話private/public distinction文獻的意思,gender部分老生常談毫無新意。社會學寫作什麼時候又能脫離研究者的政治立場?若是真的脫離又怎麼能精彩?相比之下Hochschild同題材書真的好一大截。
評分呼應當下中國密集型母職的興起。不是人類學的寫法,篇幅略拖遝,核心部分的案例比較更適閤寫成論文。
Competing Devotions 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載