By pairing translations of Gorgias and Rhetoric, along with an outstanding introductory essay, Joe Sachs demonstrates Aristotle's response to Plato. If in the Gorgias Plato probes the question of what is problematic in rhetoric, in Rhetoric, Aristotle continues the thread by looking at what makes rhetoric useful. By juxtaposing the two texts, an interesting "conversation" is illuminatedone which students of philosophy and rhetoric will find key in their analytical pursuits.
發表於2024-12-28
Gorgias and Rhetoric 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
Sachs 是在美國 St. John's Annapolis 的老師(已退休?),他的譯本非常注意文本細微處而不會籠統用同樣的詞譯不同的原文,於是不懂古希臘文的學生可以用他的譯本作研究或者與原文對照練習古希臘文。這本的注解也很有幫助,將柏拉圖的 Gorgias 和亞裏斯多德的 Rhetoric 對勘非...
評分在對話的早些時候,蘇格拉底擊敗瞭修辭學傢高爾吉亞(Gorgias)和他的追隨者波洛斯(Polus)。高爾吉亞的弱點在於他不願區分知識與行為,也就是說,他不承認一個人在明知道何為義和不義的情況下,還會做不義之事,因而他就“會不會有人將修辭作為不義的工具”這點産生瞭自相矛...
評分在對話的早些時候,蘇格拉底擊敗瞭修辭學傢高爾吉亞(Gorgias)和他的追隨者波洛斯(Polus)。高爾吉亞的弱點在於他不願區分知識與行為,也就是說,他不承認一個人在明知道何為義和不義的情況下,還會做不義之事,因而他就“會不會有人將修辭作為不義的工具”這點産生瞭自相矛...
評分Sachs 是在美國 St. John's Annapolis 的老師(已退休?),他的譯本非常注意文本細微處而不會籠統用同樣的詞譯不同的原文,於是不懂古希臘文的學生可以用他的譯本作研究或者與原文對照練習古希臘文。這本的注解也很有幫助,將柏拉圖的 Gorgias 和亞裏斯多德的 Rhetoric 對勘非...
評分在對話的早些時候,蘇格拉底擊敗瞭修辭學傢高爾吉亞(Gorgias)和他的追隨者波洛斯(Polus)。高爾吉亞的弱點在於他不願區分知識與行為,也就是說,他不承認一個人在明知道何為義和不義的情況下,還會做不義之事,因而他就“會不會有人將修辭作為不義的工具”這點産生瞭自相矛...
圖書標籤: 哲學 古希臘 柏拉圖 Aristotle 政治哲學 亞裏士多德 SJC Plato
Why I should be a good person ?!
評分Reread for Redfield's seminar. Evaluation as a creative act; supported by myth that contains certain truth; choice between lives is no longer a choice, but a necessity that involes a re-appreciation of life itself as as survival and salvation; the modest pilot stretching his legs and contemplating about the uncertainty of his quest
評分Reread for Redfield's seminar. Evaluation as a creative act; supported by myth that contains certain truth; choice between lives is no longer a choice, but a necessity that involes a re-appreciation of life itself as as survival and salvation; the modest pilot stretching his legs and contemplating about the uncertainty of his quest
評分Why I should be a good person ?!
評分Sachs的譯作我一直很喜歡,不過對於不通原文的讀者,要讀懂譯作也必須具備摳細節的習慣。
Gorgias and Rhetoric 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載