The scientific study of man:
Is impeded by the anxiety arousing overlap between subject and observer,
Which requires an analysis of the nature and locus of the partition between the two;
Must compensate for the partialness of communication between subject and observer on the conscious level; but
Must avoid the temptation to compensate for the completeness of communication between subject and observer on the unconscious level,
Which arouses anxiety and therefore also countertransference reactions,
Distorting the perception and interpretation of the data, and
Producing countertransference resistances masquerading as methodology, which cause further sui generis distortions.
Since the existence of the observer, his observational activities and his anxieties (even in self observation) produce distortions which it is not only technically but also logically impossible to eliminate,
Any effective behavioral science methodology must treat these disturbances as the most significant and characteristic data of behavioral science research, and
Must use the subjectivity inherent in all observation as the royal road to an authentic, rather than fictitious, objectivity,
Which must be defined in terms of what is really possible, rather than in terms of what 'should be.'
When ignored, or warded off by means of countertransference resistances masquerading as methodology, these 'disturbances' become sources of uncontrolled and uncontrollable error, although
When treated as basic and characteristic data of behavioral science they are more valid and more productive of insight than any other type of datum.
In short, behavioral science data arouse anxieties, which are warded off by a countertransference inspired pseudo-methodology; this maneuver is responsible for nearly all the defects of behavioral science. (pp. xvi-xvii)
發表於2025-01-11
From Anxiety to Method in the Behavioral Sciences 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
Qualitative Methods的入門讀物是George Devereux的From Anxiety to Method in the Behavioral Sciences。作者自稱“弗洛伊德主義的人類學傢”。這書用詞極其彆扭。好多在我看來已是稀鬆平常的道理,在書裏就變成個一時半會理解不瞭的術語。比如研究者對於問題重要性的判斷往往...
評分Qualitative Methods的入門讀物是George Devereux的From Anxiety to Method in the Behavioral Sciences。作者自稱“弗洛伊德主義的人類學傢”。這書用詞極其彆扭。好多在我看來已是稀鬆平常的道理,在書裏就變成個一時半會理解不瞭的術語。比如研究者對於問題重要性的判斷往往...
評分1、CASES: Devereux’s fragmented writing style is something we are not familiar with. Many cases are left without any clear and direct interpretation. Which of Devereux’s cases did you find helpful? Were there any instances in which the meaning of a case w...
評分Qualitative Methods的入門讀物是George Devereux的From Anxiety to Method in the Behavioral Sciences。作者自稱“弗洛伊德主義的人類學傢”。這書用詞極其彆扭。好多在我看來已是稀鬆平常的道理,在書裏就變成個一時半會理解不瞭的術語。比如研究者對於問題重要性的判斷往往...
評分Qualitative Methods的入門讀物是George Devereux的From Anxiety to Method in the Behavioral Sciences。作者自稱“弗洛伊德主義的人類學傢”。這書用詞極其彆扭。好多在我看來已是稀鬆平常的道理,在書裏就變成個一時半會理解不瞭的術語。比如研究者對於問題重要性的判斷往往...
圖書標籤: Methodology Science 心理分析 人類學 計劃中 情緒 anthropology Methods
From Anxiety to Method in the Behavioral Sciences 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載