发表于2024-12-26
Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 古希腊 古典学 蛮族 思想 异族 古典
In this book Jonathan Hall seeks to demonstrate that the ethnic groups of ancient Greece, like many ethnic groups throughout the world today, were not ultimately racial, linguistic, religious or cultural groups, but social groups whose 'origins' in extraneous territories were just as often imagined as they were real. Adopting an explicitly anthropological point of view, he examines the evidence of literature, archaeology and linguistics to elucidate the nature of ethnic identity in ancient Greece. Rather than treating Greek ethnic groups as 'natural' or 'essential' - let alone 'racial' - entities, he emphasises the active, constructive and dynamic role of ethnography, genealogy, material culture and language in shaping ethnic consciousness. An introductory chapter outlines the history of the study of ethnicity in Greek antiquity.
关于围绕阿尔戈斯的族群身份的具体案例讨论非常精彩,对于前期学术观点的梳理也很好。后面族群性与考古学和语言学的内容由于缺乏知识背景,所以不是太能读懂。
评分Classical
评分本科最爱读Jonathan Hall的著作,本本精读。。。此乃这位美国学者关于古希腊族群研究的开拓性著作。其中,关于古希腊族群认同研究“原生主义”与“工具主义”的讨论以及古希腊希波战争前后族群认同所呈现的“对立性”与“聚合性“的探讨甚是经典。
评分Classical
评分个人想法较多,与J Hall的观点也有些冲突。不敢妄议,经典著作还是得一读再读。
Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书