Bernard Silberman has written extensively on Japanese government and has recently compared state-building in 19th century Japan and Europe in Cages of Reason: The Rise of the Rational State in France, Japan, the United States, and Great Britain. He is also interested more generally in bureaucracies and organizational politics. Other books by Silberman include Ministers of Modernization and Japan in Crisis: Essays on Taisho Democracy (co-editor with H.D. Harootunian). He is Director of the Workshop on East Asia.
发表于2024-11-21
Cages of Reason 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 比较政治 政治学 社会学 官僚政治 国家建设 国家研究 英文原版 政治史
Blending political, historical, and sociological analysis, Bernard S. Silberman offers a provocative explanation for the bureaucratic development of the modern state. The study of modern state bureaucracy has its origins in Max Weber's analysis of the modes of social domination, which Silberman takes as his starting point.
Whereas Weber contends that the administration of all modern nation-states would eventually converge in one form characterized by rationality and legal authority, Silberman argues that the process of bureaucratic rationalization took, in fact, two courses. One path is characterized by permeable organizational boundaries and the allocation of information by "professionals." The other features well-defined boundaries and the allocation of information by organizational rules. Through case studies of France, Japan, the United States, and Great Britain, Silberman demonstrates that this divergence stems from differences in leadership structure and in levels of uncertainty about leadership succession in the nineteenth century.
Silberman concludes that the rise of bureacratic rationality was primarily a response to political problems rather than social and economic concerns. Cages of Reason demonstrates how rationalization can have occurred over a wide range of cultures at various levels of economic development. It will be of considerable interest to readers in a number of disciplines: political science, sociology, history, and public administration.
"Silberman has produced an invaluable, densely packed work that those with deep knowledge of public administrative development will find extremely rewarding." —David H. Rosenbloom, American Political Science Review
"An erudite, incisive, and vibrant book, the product of intensive study and careful reflection. Given its innovative theoretical framework and the wealth of historical materials contained in it, this study will generate debate and stimulate research in sociology, political science, and organizational theory. It is undoubtedly the best book on the comparative evolution of the modern state published in the last decade."—Mauro F. Guillen, Contemporary Sociology
有深度、历史研究够详细,几乎可以作为四国政治发展史来读,但冗长啰嗦,文笔不好。韦伯式官僚制理想型的实践考察,不同的历史发展形成不同的社会阶级和政治结构(主要是政党政治vs社会网络政治),面对不确定性和权力交接问题的领导人开发出组织至上vs专业个人主导两种不同的官僚模式,所谓理性其实是一种政治选择。政党政治下主导政党主要担心的问题是官僚组织能否有效执行政党决议,故推行组织至上、法条规范约束力大、个人以有限资质投考然后接受组织内培训和内化的官僚制度模式,这方面以英国美国为主,但由于美国政党政治冒起较晚,彭德尔顿法更是迟迟才出现,故美国总统在官僚首长委派方面权力仍大,任命职位多。网络政治下领导者担忧权力交接造成政绩抹杀,故重视官僚制度内个人专业操守、强调个人的资质和按资历晋升,以日本法国为代表。
评分太高級了這書。。。
评分太高級了這書。。。
评分看了C6.对日本的兴趣趋于零,还用这么多奇怪的词,真蛋疼
评分有深度、历史研究够详细,几乎可以作为四国政治发展史来读,但冗长啰嗦,文笔不好。韦伯式官僚制理想型的实践考察,不同的历史发展形成不同的社会阶级和政治结构(主要是政党政治vs社会网络政治),面对不确定性和权力交接问题的领导人开发出组织至上vs专业个人主导两种不同的官僚模式,所谓理性其实是一种政治选择。政党政治下主导政党主要担心的问题是官僚组织能否有效执行政党决议,故推行组织至上、法条规范约束力大、个人以有限资质投考然后接受组织内培训和内化的官僚制度模式,这方面以英国美国为主,但由于美国政党政治冒起较晚,彭德尔顿法更是迟迟才出现,故美国总统在官僚首长委派方面权力仍大,任命职位多。网络政治下领导者担忧权力交接造成政绩抹杀,故重视官僚制度内个人专业操守、强调个人的资质和按资历晋升,以日本法国为代表。
Cages of Reason 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书