This absorbing and closely documented book challenges the conventional wisdom about the Sino/Indian conflict which reached its climax in the border war of 1962. Reasonable, peaceable India, victim of unprovoked Chinese aggression --- such is the general view. But Neville Maxwell's dispassionate account of the policies and actions which led to the border war shows that the truth was very different.
First recounting the history of the disputed boundaries, the author shows that a diplomatic settlement need not have been difficult to achieve --- then traces the policy decisions taken in India early in the 1950s which blocked the way. The failed Nehru/Chou Enlai summit meeting in New Dehli in 1960 marked the effective end to any hopes of a negotiated settlement. After that another story begins; the attempt of the Indian government to use military force to push the Chinese out of territory India claimed and the resistance of the Army to a policy which the soldiers knew was wholly beyond their power to implement.
That resistance was eroded by politics and favouritism and late in 1961 India launched the "Forward policy", a direct military challenge to China. The point of unavoidable collision approached through the following summer and was reached in the climax of the border war, which saw India's army in the north-east shatter under the Chinese assault.
Neville Maxwell is uniquely qualified to write this book. He reported these events for The Times as their South Asia correspondent, augmenting and reappraising his understanding of the dispute as a senior fellow at the London School of Oriental and African Studies. In his research, he was given access to unpublished Indian government papers and reports.
Born in London in 1926, Neville Maxwell went to school in Australia, served in the AIF in 1945, and continued his education at McGill University and Cambridge. Working first as a reporter in Australia, he joined The Times in 1955 and spent three years in the Washington bureau before coming to New Delhi in August 1959 as South Asia correspondent. He held this assignment for eight years, travelling widely through India and the sub-continent; and left in July 1967 to make a study of the Sino-Indian dispute as a senior fellow at the School of Oriental and African Studies of London University. He is now joining the Institute of Commonwealth Studies at Oxford.
發表於2024-12-23
India's China War 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
這本書雖然已很有年代感瞭,導緻現在已經買不到正版,拿到手的書竟然是粗劣的影印版,好在基本不影響閱讀。在讀這本書之前,對中印戰爭中國戰勝後為什麼退的那迅速,那麼堅決很是疑惑,雖然知道那時有和蘇聯交惡的原因。從這本書作者詳盡且有些絮叨的記述中(雖然大部分是印度...
評分在寫這個書評之前,本人還未有幸閱讀本書。按照常理來講,是沒有資格來寫的,但是還是見獵心喜,耐不住心癢,鬍亂謅幾句。 三聯書店齣版的書,應當是還不錯的,畢竟人傢也是有把關的。 1971年齣版,本人覺得這或許是個敏感的年份,70年代的舊事在這裏就不贅言瞭,大傢都知道。...
評分其實這本書有些觀點還是比較片麵的,把阿三寫的太蠢瞭,讓讀者覺得作為一個曾經號稱“世界第三”的大國,領導人竟然如此愚蠢,中國反復提齣友好平等和建議都不接受。 實際上當時天朝當時連聯閤國席位都沒有絕大多數國傢不承認TG政權,之前的後盾毛子又跟天朝開始翻臉瞭可謂雪上...
評分 評分圖書標籤: 國際政治 印度 中國 戰爭 曆史 冷戰 鬥篷 中亞
阿三六十年來真心是沒什麼長進……
評分“你不問,我就不主動提。英國搶的就是我的。跟你來往已經是給你麵子,不要把理所當然的事情和我討價還價”:當年的三哥恰獨立門戶,風華正茂,親美蘇又自立不結盟運動領主,自然有自信看不起叫花子一樣的新中國。對照今天印度的對華戰略,簡直就是個死亡遊輪循環。
評分阿三六十年來真心是沒什麼長進……
評分“你不問,我就不主動提。英國搶的就是我的。跟你來往已經是給你麵子,不要把理所當然的事情和我討價還價”:當年的三哥恰獨立門戶,風華正茂,親美蘇又自立不結盟運動領主,自然有自信看不起叫花子一樣的新中國。對照今天印度的對華戰略,簡直就是個死亡遊輪循環。
評分阿三六十年來真心是沒什麼長進……
India's China War 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載