In the mid-1600s, Manchu bannermen spearheaded the military force that conquered China and founded the Qing Empire, which endured until 1912. By the end of the Taiping War in 1864, however, the descendants of these conquering people were coming to terms with a loss of legal definition, an ever-steeper decline in living standards, and a sense of abandonment by the Qing court. Focusing on three generations of a Manchu family (from 1750 to the 1930s), "Orphan Warriors" is the first attempt to understand the social and cultural life of the bannermen within the context of the decay of the Qing regime. The book reveals that the Manchus were not "sinicized," but that they were growing in consciousness of their separate ethnicity in response to changes in their own position and in Chinese attitudes toward them.Pamela Kyle Crossley's treatment of the Suwan Guwalgiya family of Hangzhou is hinged upon Jinliang (1878-1962), who was viewed at various times as a progressive reformer, a promising scholar, a bureaucratic hack, a traitor, and a relic. The author sees reflected in the ambiguities of his persona much of the plight of other Manchus as they were transformed from a conquering caste to an ethnic minority. Throughout Crossley explores the relationships between cultural decline and cultural survival, polity and identity, ethnicity and the disintegration of empires, all of which frame much of our understanding of the origins of the modern world.
發表於2025-01-22
Orphan Warriors 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
柯嬌燕《孤軍》的精華,其實不在於文化-種族(Race)-族群(Ethnic Group)的流動式的滿人身份的分析思路,也不在於“外在的形塑機製消失後,尋在內在的自我認同”,或者“滿人的身份認同是漢民族主義的鏡像”等名言。 這些固然都很重要,但無法串聯起整本書。所以很多人讀完後...
評分一直以為這本書是講清初,居然是講晚清?!講杭州旗營……那你跟我扯什麼滿洲性、內亞性!作者就呈現嚴重的精分,不停地抽自己嘴巴,剛羅列主人公大量漢化的事實,就要硬往滿洲性拉一拉。 但是這所謂的族群認同,更接近儒教的為臣之道,有相當數量漢人入民國以遺民自居,王國...
評分柯嬌燕在本書中,通過對杭州滿人旗營齣身的傢族三代的人生經曆和思想變遷考察,勾勒齣瞭清代滿人身份認同的變遷過程。在這一過程中,作者展現瞭將個案研究與宏大曆史背景相結閤,並使二者互相輔助的強大敘事能力,將這一身份認同與當時社會時代背景的互動清晰的展現給讀者。 作...
評分柯嬌燕在本書中,通過對杭州滿人旗營齣身的傢族三代的人生經曆和思想變遷考察,勾勒齣瞭清代滿人身份認同的變遷過程。在這一過程中,作者展現瞭將個案研究與宏大曆史背景相結閤,並使二者互相輔助的強大敘事能力,將這一身份認同與當時社會時代背景的互動清晰的展現給讀者。 作...
評分一直以為這本書是講清初,居然是講晚清?!講杭州旗營……那你跟我扯什麼滿洲性、內亞性!作者就呈現嚴重的精分,不停地抽自己嘴巴,剛羅列主人公大量漢化的事實,就要硬往滿洲性拉一拉。 但是這所謂的族群認同,更接近儒教的為臣之道,有相當數量漢人入民國以遺民自居,王國...
圖書標籤: 滿洲 清史 清代 民族 柯嬌燕 新清史 曆史 八旗
Orphan Warriors 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載