I was blown away by this book when I first read it, back in the 1970s. And I give it three stars because it did introduce me to many of the ideas and thinkers Hofstadter highlights. But I can't give it more than that. Hofstadter overstates the significance of social Darwinism. It wasn't the whole of the case for laissez-faire economics. After all, David Ricardo made that case well before Darwin saw any finches on any islands. And Ricardo's disciple, Harriet Martineau, was popularizing and idealizing the free-market case in the 1830s, still long before Darwin or Spencer or the rest of this lot. In the US, the arguments of classical economists combined with the old Puritan ethos to gain force. One interpretation of Darwinism strengthened such thoughts, but RH takes that out of context.
发表于2024-12-22
Social Darwinism in American Thought 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 美国 历史 社会 霍夫斯塔特 进化论 西方 社会达尔文主义 社会学
From Publishers Weekly
The much-honored late historian Hofstadter inaugurated the study of social Darwinism in his 1944 Ph.D. thesis, reprinted here with an introduction by noted contemporary historian Foner.
结构、写法、提问-问题意识、引用资料都值得我多次琢磨品味
评分结构、写法、提问-问题意识、引用资料都值得我多次琢磨品味
评分我也要写出这个水平的博士论文来
评分结构、写法、提问-问题意识、引用资料都值得我多次琢磨品味
评分我也要写出这个水平的博士论文来
Social Darwinism in American Thought 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书