发表于2024-11-22
Of Hospitality 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: Derrida 理论 德里达 哲学 列维纳斯 法国哲学 政治学 希腊哲学
These two lectures by Jacques Derrida, "Foreigner Question" and "Step of Hospitality/No Hospitality," derive from a series of seminars on "hospitality" conducted by Derrida in Paris, January 1996. His seminars, in France and in America, have become something of an institution over the years, the place where he presents the ongoing evolution of his thought in a remarkable combination of thoroughly mapped-out positions, sketches of new material, and exchanges with students and interlocutors. As has become a pattern in Derrida's recent work, the form of this presentation is a self-conscious enactment of its content. The book consists of two texts on facing pages. "Invitation" by Anne Dufourmantelle appears on the left (an invitation that of course originates in a response), clarifying and inflecting Derrida's "response" on the right. The interaction between them not only enacts the "hospitality" under discussion, but preserves something of the rhythms of teaching. The volume also characteristically combines careful readings of canonical texts and philosophical topics with attention to the most salient events in the contemporary world, using "hospitality" as a means of rethinking a range of political and ethical situations. "Hospitality" is viewed as a question of what arrives at the borders, in the initial surprise of contact with an other, a stranger, a foreigner. For example, Antigone is revisited in light of the question of impossible mourning; "Oedipus at Colonus" is read via concerns that also apply to teletechnology; the trial of Socrates is brought into conjunction with the televised funeral of Francois Mitterrand.
最骚的部分当然是mourning of the impossibility of mourning啦
评分最骚的部分当然是mourning of the impossibility of mourning啦
评分排版不能更奇葩= = 起承转合之处没有全懂,谈论语言的immobility之处灵光一现,各种兴奋。第一篇中苏格拉底与安提戈涅的分析真是让人牙痒痒:德里达不存心为读者设置迷障的时候是有多神。可惜只有两篇,具体hospitality性质还得再读。
评分仔细重读了两遍,又灵又神。苏格拉底申辩中外人身份所指向的“协议”,技术对“家”的倾入导致好客的不可能,同时是康德“论人是否有说谎的权利”对这个问题的拆解,自然的humane的部分subordinates pure self of politics,laws和the law的非辩证式antigomy、它们形成的复数的the laws。对俄狄浦斯人生最后一程解读应该是列维纳斯绝对的好客的一个补注,但这段怎么都没看懂。待补完的:剧和两章柏拉图。
评分德里达经常被文学批评家使用,似乎鲜有关注他和法国社会学传统的对话。(不过参加的美国人seminar拿这两篇文章来讨论难民的universal human rights 问题……)
Of Hospitality 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书