Daniel Leese is Assistant Professor at the Institute of Chinese Studies at Ludwig-Maximilians-University in Munich. He is the editor of Brill's Encyclopedia of China (2008).
发表于2024-12-22
Mao Cult 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
图书标签: 历史 中国研究 文革 海外中国研究 毛澤東 毛泽东 文化大革命 台湾
Mao Zedong's political and cultural legacy remains potent even in today's China. There have been many books that have explored his posthumous legacy, but none that has scrutinized the cult of Mao and the massive worship that was fostered around him at the height of his powers during the Cultural Revolution. This riveting book is the first to do so. By analyzing previously secret archival documents, obscure objects, and political pamphlets, Daniel Leese traces the tumultuous history of the cult within the Communist Party and at the grassroots level. The Party leadership's original intention was to develop a prominent brand symbol, which would compete with the nationalists' elevation of Chiang Kai-shek. They did not, however, anticipate that Mao would use this symbolic power to mobilize Chinese youth to rebel against party bureaucracy itself. The result was anarchy, and when the army was called in, it relied on mandatory rituals of worship, such as daily reading of the Little Red Book or performances of 'the loyalty dance', to restore order. Such fascinating detail sheds light not only on the personality cult of Mao, but also on hero-worship in other traditions.
通过政治运动的演变来解读红宝书和重要文献,这个路径是有意义的。但是我真的对外国人能有多了解国人感到遗憾;比红太阳差的不是一星半点。
评分读的中文版,有点失望。没有想看的吉尔兹式的仪式、象征物的深描,只有布迪厄一类浅层次的分析。还有就是图像资料的解读分析太少了。比较启发的是讲“忠字舞”的自发性。文革小组反感表忠行为,是因为这意味着每一个人都能借此获取符号资本。
评分中文版。落脚点还是在政治上,讲述卡里斯玛权威化作象征资本与某种激励机制,但对于个人崇拜与狂热行动之间的转化机制仍然云里雾里,也缺乏对于崇拜的具体仪式、符号、象征物的深描。中央与民众争夺象征资本的过程以及“象征资本”本身的阐释,以及最后崇拜的消退过程,可与王绍光的研究相互参看。但“象征资本”这个概念的运用,同“理性人”相比也没有太超越。
评分借标,看的是中译本。
评分四星减。导论和结论比较精彩,中间讲着讲着线就丢掉了的感觉。没时间看具体历史事件梳理的话,只看结论没有任何损失。
Mao Cult 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书