Pang Laikwan is a Professor of Cultural Studies at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, and author of Creativity and Its Discontents.
Cultural production under Mao, and how artists and thinkers found autonomy in a culture of conformity
In the 1950s, a French journalist joked that the Chinese were “blue ants under the red flag,” dressing identically and even moving in concert like robots. When the Cultural Revolution officially began, this uniformity seemed to extend to the mind. From the outside, China had become a monotonous world, a place of endless repetition and imitation, but a closer look reveals a range of cultural experiences, which also provided individuals with an obscure sense of freedom.
In The Art of Cloning, Pang Laikwan examines this period in Chinese history when ordinary citizens read widely, traveled extensively through the country, and engaged in a range of cultural and artistic activities. The freedom they experienced, argues Pang, differs from the freedom, under Western capitalism, to express individuality through a range of consumer products. But it was far from boring and was possessed of its own kind of diversity.
Reviews
“A thoughtful contribution to the writing of a new and nuanced cultural history of the Cultural Revolution. Pang’s work brings a fresh optic to the question of how Chinese people lived, felt and made art in a fraught age of revolution.”
– Andrew Jones, author of Yellow Music: Media Culture and Colonial Modernity in the Chinese Jazz Age
“Pang Laikwan’s meticulous research draws the reader into a world in which this art of copying, of making models and of typifications framed the cultural and political realm and then spread across the social landscape to fashion life itself. Offering new and exciting insights based upon impeccable research, this is one book about the Cultural Revolution that should not be missed.”
– Michael Dutton, coauthor of Beijing Time
“A major intervention into a fraught field. Luminously opening new and old channels of inquiry, Pang forces a reconsideration of the processes and politics of cultural production in China’s Cultural Revolutionary decade.”
– Rebecca Karl, author of Mao Zedong and China in the Twentieth-Century World: A Concise History
發表於2025-03-26
The Art of Cloning 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
圖書標籤: 文化研究 海外中國研究 文革 彭麗君 曆史 香港 社會學 視覺文化
讀的是港中文三十書係的中譯本,但那個版本不能評論所以就在這裏標記瞭。這本書的主要研究對象是萌革期間的文化生産與實踐。在萌革期間,雖然知識分子等“文化人”群體遭到迫害,八部“樣闆戲”統治著舞颱與銀幕,但中國當時的文化領域絕非空無一物。在為鄭智服務的文化産品的創造與“復製”中,群眾仍然擁有某種意義上的“自由”。即便是官方為鄭智宣傳而創作的文藝作品,同樣也有美學的考慮。例如即便在當前中國也是小眾愛好的芭蕾舞,在萌革期間卻成為八部樣闆戲中兩部的錶演形式,因此從後世看來,萌革反而成瞭中國芭蕾發展史上的高光時刻。萌革當然是不義的,而且一開始就注定失敗的結局,因為既要求革命同時又完全馴服於權力的革命者從不存在,貓主義者的烏托邦也多齣於後人的想象。但是以閉口不說的緘默把這段曆史糊弄過去,同樣並不明智。
評分港版
評分作者對藝術文化似乎有一個開放、自由空間的前設,由此在最壓迫的年代尋找藝術的可能性。但這前設很可能是西方文化語境,而難以對應中國現代政治運動中的藝術操作。
評分其實我讀的是中文版,但是中文版已經被。。。。
評分從主體的型塑、社會性的模仿和宣傳三個觀念探討CR期間的文化生産。個人活動並不屈服於集體主義的召喚,而個人的能動性能夠時刻挑戰官方既定的認知思路與範式。各類繁多材料的整閤讓整本書讀起來非常過癮,但是可能也就造成瞭許多地方點到為止。部分內容缺少瞭深入的探討。這段過去的曆史有太多太多的迷幻色彩,對我們後人來說,不斷地觸碰底綫也是一種“附魅”和嘗試“驅魅”的過程。
The Art of Cloning 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載