发表于2024-12-19
Jerusalem 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书
还行。作者观察还是一如既往犀利。画风简明扼。感觉不如北朝鲜那本好看。可能因为一是本身槽点较少,二是耶路撒冷还是离我们的生活远了点。作者还有本画深圳,一本画缅甸的。画深圳那本也比较一般,因为作者所画是90年代中期的生活,离现在时间稍嫌久远,国内情况也已改变很多了。
评分还行。作者观察还是一如既往犀利。画风简明扼。感觉不如北朝鲜那本好看。可能因为一是本身槽点较少,二是耶路撒冷还是离我们的生活远了点。作者还有本画深圳,一本画缅甸的。画深圳那本也比较一般,因为作者所画是90年代中期的生活,离现在时间稍嫌久远,国内情况也已改变很多了。
评分还行。作者观察还是一如既往犀利。画风简明扼。感觉不如北朝鲜那本好看。可能因为一是本身槽点较少,二是耶路撒冷还是离我们的生活远了点。作者还有本画深圳,一本画缅甸的。画深圳那本也比较一般,因为作者所画是90年代中期的生活,离现在时间稍嫌久远,国内情况也已改变很多了。
评分还行。作者观察还是一如既往犀利。画风简明扼。感觉不如北朝鲜那本好看。可能因为一是本身槽点较少,二是耶路撒冷还是离我们的生活远了点。作者还有本画深圳,一本画缅甸的。画深圳那本也比较一般,因为作者所画是90年代中期的生活,离现在时间稍嫌久远,国内情况也已改变很多了。
评分还行。作者观察还是一如既往犀利。画风简明扼。感觉不如北朝鲜那本好看。可能因为一是本身槽点较少,二是耶路撒冷还是离我们的生活远了点。作者还有本画深圳,一本画缅甸的。画深圳那本也比较一般,因为作者所画是90年代中期的生活,离现在时间稍嫌久远,国内情况也已改变很多了。
图书标签: 漫画 耶路撒冷 游记 GuyDelisle Guy_Delisle 英语 绘本 纪实
" Delisle's books are] some of the most effective and fully realized travel writing out there." --NPR
Acclaimed graphic memoirist Guy Delisle returns with his strongest work yet, a thoughtful and moving travelogue about life in Israel. Delisle and his family spent a year in East Jerusalem as part of his wife's work with the nongovernmental organization Doctors Without Borders. They were there for the short but brutal Gaza War, a three-week-long military strike that resulted in more than a thousand Palestinian deaths. In his interactions with the emergency medical team sent in by Doctors Without Borders, Delisle eloquently plumbs the depths of the conflict.
Some of the most moving moments in "Jerusalem "are the interactions between Delisle and Palestinian art students as they explain the motivations for their work. Interspersed with these simply told, affecting stories of suffering, Delisle deftly and often drolly recounts the quotidian: crossing checkpoints, going kosher for Passover, and befriending other stay-at-home dads with NGO-employed wives.
"Jerusalem "evinces Delisle's renewed fascination with architecture and landscape as political and apolitical, with studies of highways, villages, and olive groves recurring alongside depictions of the newly erected West Bank Barrier and illegal Israeli settlements. His drawn line is both sensitive and fair, assuming nothing and drawing everything. "Jerusalem "showcases once more Delisle's mastery of the travelogue.
love his comics! learned so much about Israel-Palestine relation from the book
评分我觉得这是我看过的Guy的漫画里最好看的一本,平壤我觉得有点猎奇,缅甸更关注日常生活,这本耶路撒冷还涉及了宗教争论,终于涨了姿势:原来犹太人和阿拉伯人这么不合,原来加沙这么危险,原来以色列和巴勒斯坦仇恨这么深。
评分“三部曲”中个人感觉最好的一本,可以当作了解巴以关系的敲门砖。
评分需要边读边查wiki,理解难度明显比<平壤>和<缅甸>大,特别是节日历史人物地区方面。这个区域的冲突无药可救了,宗教真是个麻烦的事务,将正常人的逻辑思维能力都抹去,只剩下对理想国的飘渺憧憬和对异教徒的无情驱赶。即使升级成家庭主夫,画面里还是充斥着孤单的宅,到哪依然是个局外人。
评分大概因为在耶路撒冷呆的时间比深圳久,这本的故事要有意思一些,不过还是不大喜欢作者的叙事口吻,总觉得缺一点关爱。 读完之后感慨大概是,嗯好吧,来自发达国家的外派员工们其实怎样都无法走入当地人的生活圈子里,雾里看花也只是满足一下想要远观人的趣味吧。
Jerusalem 2024 pdf epub mobi 电子书