Henrietta Harrison is professor of modern Chinese studies at the University of Oxford and the Stanley Ho Tutorial Fellow in Chinese History at Pembroke College. Her books include The Man Awakened from Dreams and The Missionary’s Curse and Other Tales from a Chinese Catholic Village. She lives in Oxford, England.
The 1793 British embassy to China, which led to Lord George Macartney’s fraught encounter with the Qianlong emperor, has often been viewed as a clash of cultures fueled by the East’s disinterest in the West. In The Perils of Interpreting, Henrietta Harrison presents a more nuanced picture, ingeniously shifting the historical lens to focus on Macartney’s two interpreters at that meeting—Li Zibiao and George Thomas Staunton. Who were these two men? How did they intervene in the exchanges that they mediated? And what did these exchanges mean for them? From Galway to Chengde, and from political intrigues to personal encounters, Harrison reassesses a pivotal moment in British-China relations. She shows that there were Chinese who were familiar with the West, but growing tensions endangered those who embraced both cultures and would eventually culminate in the Opium Wars.
Harrison demonstrates that the Qing court’s ignorance about the British did not simply happen, but was manufactured through the repression of cultural go-betweens like Li and Staunton. She traces Li’s influence as Macartney’s interpreter, the pressures Li faced in China as a result, and his later years in hiding. Staunton interpreted successfully for the British East India Company in Canton, but as Chinese anger grew against British imperial expansion in South Asia, he was compelled to flee to England. Harrison contends that in silencing expert voices, the Qing court missed an opportunity to gain insights that might have prevented a losing conflict with Britain.
Uncovering the lives of two overlooked figures, The Perils of Interpreting offers a valuable argument for cross-cultural understanding in a better-connected world.
發表於2024-11-07
The Perils of Interpreting 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
圖書標籤:
以近代史史料之繁復,能夠爬梳多語言檔案、洞悉其中的草蛇灰綫、又能以“深描”的敘事方式把大小曆史結閤起來的學者不多,瀋老師算一位。數十年來關於馬戛爾尼使團訪華的研究汗牛充棟,但作者卻彆齣心裁地將目光投注在瞭此行的兩位譯員身上,也因此有瞭許多有趣的發現:比如拉丁文纔是翻譯過程中的medium language,因為華人李自標自幼在那不勒斯學院接受的是古典學教育,並沒有相應的英文知識,隻能靠拉丁文與使節團進行溝通;以及使節團提齣的天主教傳教自由的要求其實是李齣於自己的天主教徒背景而夾帶進的“私貨”,盡管並未獲得成功。作者認為嘉慶時期對這種in-between的文化中介者的不信任導緻瞭譯者的疏離,進而造成決策者對英帝國信息的缺失和誤判。如果最後沒有又迴到檢討鴉片戰爭失敗原因的老路上就更好瞭……
評分作為曆史讀物確實為反歐洲中心論又添瞭一把柴火。讀起來很流暢很有趣。不過,可能從側麵也反映齣瞭一些曆史作品的局限性。比如作者說是因為這些cultural mediator給決策者傳遞瞭錯誤的信息所以纔導緻瞭很多我們不想看到的後果。但是這也隻是一種cultural exchange的情況。(不過還是給proposal靈感來源五星!
評分以近代史史料之繁復,能夠爬梳多語言檔案、洞悉其中的草蛇灰綫、又能以“深描”的敘事方式把大小曆史結閤起來的學者不多,瀋老師算一位。數十年來關於馬戛爾尼使團訪華的研究汗牛充棟,但作者卻彆齣心裁地將目光投注在瞭此行的兩位譯員身上,也因此有瞭許多有趣的發現:比如拉丁文纔是翻譯過程中的medium language,因為華人李自標自幼在那不勒斯學院接受的是古典學教育,並沒有相應的英文知識,隻能靠拉丁文與使節團進行溝通;以及使節團提齣的天主教傳教自由的要求其實是李齣於自己的天主教徒背景而夾帶進的“私貨”,盡管並未獲得成功。作者認為嘉慶時期對這種in-between的文化中介者的不信任導緻瞭譯者的疏離,進而造成決策者對英帝國信息的缺失和誤判。如果最後沒有又迴到檢討鴉片戰爭失敗原因的老路上就更好瞭……
評分1. 史料翔實,句句有齣處。 2. (世界)曆史真的不像我腦瓜裏記得的那樣簡單。eg.虎門銷煙 3. Dont kill the msger, 同理,dont kill the interpreter. eg.簽訂《NJ條約》時,我方沒有自帶口譯員,因為不敢接活。美在敘利亞行動的口譯員。 4. 李自標和小斯當東的經曆,放在今天也是不多的。
評分鴉戰之前,中英兩國都有對彼此有所瞭解的民眾在,為何這場戰爭沒能避免?關於異國的知識如何傳播,而這些知識又能對一個國傢的外交決策産生多大程度的影響…….種種在本書中展開的問題,都能讓今日的我們有“似曾相識之感”。 (小斯當東和李自標都是其祖國的“文化異鄉人”,這點竟讓我很能共情…….
The Perils of Interpreting 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載