In Qing Colonial Enterprise, Laura Hostetler shows how Qing China (1636-1911) used cartography and ethnography to pursue its imperial ambitions. She argues that far from being on the periphery of developments in the early modern period, Qing China both participated in and helped shape the new emphasis on empirical scientific knowledge that was simultaneously transforming Europe--and its colonial empires--at the time.
Although mapping in China is almost as old as Chinese civilization itself, the Qing insistence on accurate, to-scale maps of their territory was a new response to the difficulties of administering a vast and growing empire. Likewise, direct observation became increasingly important to Qing ethnographic writings, such as the illustrated manuscripts known as "Miao albums" (from which twenty color paintings are reproduced in this book). These were intended to educate Qing officials about various non-Han peoples so that they could govern these groups more effectively.Hostetler's groundbreaking account will interest anyone studying the history of the early modern period and colonialism.
發表於2025-03-22
Qing Colonial Enterprise 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
本書最有意思的是導論,作者把清朝政府與同時代歐洲的殖民帝國相提並論,她期期要告訴我們,從近代早期(early modern)觀點來看,中國與歐洲的差異沒那麼大。我們老用近代歐洲的標準,去衡量前近代的中國,纔是有問題的。特別是在本書的兩個主題:地圖學與民族誌的發展上,我...
評分Although Qing Colonial Enterprise was published before China Marches West, its focus very much overlaps with Part IV of the latter work. This book explores the Qing state’s use of cartographic and ethnographic representation in the building of empire. Th...
評分本書最有意思的是導論,作者把清朝政府與同時代歐洲的殖民帝國相提並論,她期期要告訴我們,從近代早期(early modern)觀點來看,中國與歐洲的差異沒那麼大。我們老用近代歐洲的標準,去衡量前近代的中國,纔是有問題的。特別是在本書的兩個主題:地圖學與民族誌的發展上,我...
評分 評分Although Qing Colonial Enterprise was published before China Marches West, its focus very much overlaps with Part IV of the latter work. This book explores the Qing state’s use of cartographic and ethnographic representation in the building of empire. Th...
圖書標籤: 清史 海外中國研究 曆史 西南 殖民 Ethnography 新清史 Cartography
很水的一本書。導論提到早期現代的再現變化(例如,製圖術的圖像、文本描述和人物的淡齣等),集中體現帝國時空觀念的轉變,這一段非常重要,但作者寫得比較淩亂,摻雜的東西太多,沒有進一步深挖。另外注意作者與Siam Mapped(《圖繪暹羅》)的一點點對話。
評分為何要將一個如此近代的“殖民”(colonization)強加在一個premodern的Qing Empire與西南民族的互動呢?如要將大清帝國構造為一個具有近代史、全球史意義的帝國,是否能忽視清以前的中央與周邊蠻夷的政策延續性呢?如此觀念先行、西方本位的歷史寫作分明顯露齣作者在北美“新清史”中的較為極端的一種取嚮。
評分開篇貌似有大作為,中段論述看得我犯睏,到末尾語氣突然帶瞭一絲憤世嫉俗…… 苗圖的論證沒有太說服我。且看下周書評日Simon Schaffer會怎麼分析。
評分開篇貌似有大作為,中段論述看得我犯睏,到末尾語氣突然帶瞭一絲憤世嫉俗…… 苗圖的論證沒有太說服我。且看下周書評日Simon Schaffer會怎麼分析。
評分又一本導論嚇死人,正文嗬嗬嗬。最好的評價大概就是:沒有在迴答中國曆史的問題吧。。
Qing Colonial Enterprise 2025 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載