Edward J. M. Rhoads is professor of history at the University of Texas at Austin. He is the author of China's Republican Revolution: The Case of Kwangtung, 1895-1913.Winner of the Joseph Levenson Book Prize for Modern China, sponsored by The China and Inner Asia Council of the Association for Asian Studies
China's 1911-12 Revolution, which overthrew a 2000-year succession of dynasties, is thought of primarily as a change in governmental style, from imperial to republican, traditional to modern. But given that the dynasty that was overthrown—the Qing—was that of a minority ethnic group that had ruled China's Han majority for nearly three centuries, and that the revolutionaries were overwhelmingly Han, to what extent was the revolution not only anti-monarchical, but also anti-Manchu?
Edward Rhoads explores this provocative and complicated question in Manchus and Han, analyzing the evolution of the Manchus from a hereditary military caste (the "banner people") to a distinct ethnic group and then detailing the interplay and dialogue between the Manchu court and Han reformers that culminated in the dramatic changes of the early 20th century.
Until now, many scholars have assumed that the Manchus had been assimilated into Han culture long before the 1911 Revolution and were no longer separate and distinguishable. But Rhoads demonstrates that in many ways Manchus remained an alien, privileged, and distinct group. Manchus and Han is a pathbreaking study that will forever change the way historians of China view the events leading to the fall of the Qing dynasty. Likewise, it will clarify for ethnologists the unique origin of the Manchus as an occupational caste and their shifting relationship with the Han, from border people to rulers to ruled.
發表於2024-11-21
Manchus and Han 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載
——讀(美)路康樂著《滿與漢:晚清到民國初期的族群關係與政治權力,1861—1928》 中央民族大學管理學院 吳磊 徐永誌 摘要:美國學者路康樂所著《滿與漢:晚清到民國初期的族群關係與政治權力,1861—1928》一書,運用“民族—社會”的視角,著重分析瞭清末民初政治變革背景...
評分辛亥革命時鮮為人知的屠殺 10月24日,西安的滿城淪陷瞭。隨著革命軍從南麵和西麵潮水般湧入,他們把捕獲的所有居民看作潛在的敵人,不由分說地進行瞭殺戮。……如果八旗駐防城市的人口是兩萬人,那麼一半人都死瞭。而且,滿城被大規模搶劫一空。 這是辛亥革命爆發時...
評分Edward J . M. Rhoads , Manchus and Han : Ethnic Relations and Political Power in Late Qing and Early Republican China , 1861—1928 ,Seattle and London : University of Washington Press , 2000 ,394pp. 2002 年4 月初在華盛頓召開的亞洲學會第54 屆年會上, 宣...
評分辛亥革命時鮮為人知的屠殺 10月24日,西安的滿城淪陷瞭。隨著革命軍從南麵和西麵潮水般湧入,他們把捕獲的所有居民看作潛在的敵人,不由分說地進行瞭殺戮。……如果八旗駐防城市的人口是兩萬人,那麼一半人都死瞭。而且,滿城被大規模搶劫一空。 這是辛亥革命爆發時...
評分摘要:路康樂著《滿與漢》麵世以來,廣受好評。作者以“滿”“漢”對立的視角得到瞭學界的甚高評價,但他忽視對概念的界定,遺漏滿漢之外的其他族群和將滿漢完全對立緻有失真。該書的研究內容與所選研究時段明顯分離,透露齣模糊性而不便讀者理解。自蓋博堅並不確定地稱該書為...
圖書標籤: 曆史 新清史 海外中國研究 滿族 中國近代史 路康樂 民族主義 民族-國傢
一周目刷的中文版,二周目刷的英文版,還是英文版好看。當然看得人很生氣就是瞭,時而覺得載灃是不是傻,時而又覺得,經過太平天國那麼一摺騰,其實君主立憲製無論如何在中國都不太可能瞭吧。哎……這纔是真實版的“上帝死瞭,我們需要超人臨世”。可問題是,Mao's dead, so is his China.
評分相當棒,特彆厲害,真的很喜歡
評分考試臨近,加上書過期瞭,隻好囫圇吞棗地速讀瞭前兩章,幸好買瞭中文版,等考完瞭再看。
評分作者中文功底還是很深厚的,史料也很到位,關於此書看過的最好評論是狄宇宙寫的。對照漢譯本,就某章的個彆“foreigners”被翻譯成“列強”這一點,我再也不敢相信漢譯的海外漢學瞭……
評分作者中文功底還是很深厚的,史料也很到位,關於此書看過的最好評論是狄宇宙寫的。對照漢譯本,就某章的個彆“foreigners”被翻譯成“列強”這一點,我再也不敢相信漢譯的海外漢學瞭……
Manchus and Han 2024 pdf epub mobi 電子書 下載